AABRI Reviewer Information Form

+ AABRI Reviewer Information Form

AABRI Submission Review Form

Please complete all of the following sections. Make sure to leave specific comments regarding what needs to be revised if revision is necessary. If the paper is being rejected please specify what is wrong with the paper and what needs to be corrected to make it publishable.

Do not return a copy of the paper. Do not use track changes. All items must be filled in before the form can be submitted. You may copy and paste into fields.

AABRI is a COPE member. Reviewers are expected to read and comply with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers


Manuscript submission number *
Submission Title *
Reviewer Name *
Date Reviewed *
Submission Summary: (Briefly summarize the paper’s content) *
Is the submission compliant with AABRI submission requirements? *	Yes No
If not, discuss which areas are noncompliant *
Comments on Contribution: (Does the paper present new ideas or unexpected results? Do readers learn something new?) *
Comments on Writing Quality: Is the paper well written and easy to read (e.g. well structured, correct and clear language)? *
Research contribution rating *	Major Contribution Reasonable Contribution Marginal Contribution No Contribution
Submission Quality Rating: *	Exceptional, ready to publish Adequate for publication with revision Marginal, needs significant work Poor paper, needs complete rewriting as specified below
Basis in Published Research: How well is the paper integrated with current research? How current, credible and sufficient are the references (academic journals, popular press, unedited web, etc.)? *
Overall evaluation rating: On a 10 = best, 1 = worst, rate this paper? *
Recommendation for publication *	Accept as is Revise and resubmit after making changes indicated below Reject. See reasons below
Required changes / improvements needed for publication acceptance (if any) or specific reasons for rejection. If more space is necessary please email recommended changes to editorial.staff@aabri.com *

Academic and Business Research Institute
P.O. Box 2235, Ponte Vedra Beach, FL, 32004, USA
editorial.staff@aabri.com
Phone - (904)435-4330
Dr. Russell Baker, AABRI Executive Director